A Weekend with Frank Stitt of Highlands Bar & Grill

Crudo Recipe_A Weekend with Frank Stitt of Highlands Bar

As I mentioned in last year’s spring newsletter, Peay Vineyards participated in the Southern Foodways Alliance’s annual wine auction weekend at Blackberry Farm a year ago last January. As part of the festivities, we donated a line up of never before released 3 liter wines plus a two night stay at the vineyard Barn House with Alabama chef Frank Stitt from Highlands Bar & Grill in residence as your private chef. As far as I was concerned, Diane and Jim Stark were not the only winners, I got to spend a weekend with one of the country’s most accomplished, thoughtful, and modest culinary geniuses. The night before we drove to the vineyard, Frank and I went to dinner at San Francisco’s much-lauded—and rightly so—Statebird Provisions. Chef Stuart Brioza stopped by our table to say hello to Frank. We talked about the dishes in front of us and the amazing range of fresh ingredients available to California chefs. Frank is from the South and what he grows on his farm in Alabama is quite different from what we enjoy in California. The three of us began to map out our morning shopping spree at local markets but we were in need of superior protein. “Oh, I can help,” said Stuart. The next thing we knew, Stuart proffered a gorgeous, local halibut filet that was so fresh it was still in rigor mortis. Now, what to do with it?

The next evening, as Frank was preparing the halibut for the grill, we popped a bottle of Viognier and sat around the table in the Farm House kitchen chatting. As we bantered, Frank started to slice thin strips of halibut onto a plate. He began to talk flavor sensations: sweet, heat, salt, fat, umami and…boom! Out came a colorful plate of sensational crudo. This is not the first time you have seen crudo served with these ingredients but it was the first time I had seen it organically build in a chef’s brain as he reached out to grab what was fresh and put it together on the fly. It was sensational. I think we could have stopped right there and been happy with plates of halibut crudo but Frank was just getting started.


1 lb   Sushi grade white fish, halibut, cod, et al.

1       Nectarine or peach. Ripe and aromatic but not too soft or will not slice well. Can substitute with citrus, if desired

1       Avocado. Ripe but not too soft or will not slice well

1       Bunch basil, preferably small leaves

1       Lime

1 Fresh red chili pepper (or jalapeno). If desire less heat, use radish

Olive oil, not too green or strong—avoid Tuscan, if possible. Use a milder southern Italian or Californian olive oil

Rock salt & cracked black pepper (optional)

To assemble

The assembly is really a matter of trial and error and personal taste. Prepare the ingredients below and try a little of this and a little of that and see where you find the balance of flavors that you think are ideal. Also, feel free to replace the nectarine with cherry tomatoes or citrus, the basil with mint, avocado with burrata, etc.. Make the recipe yours.

1. Slice the fish across the filet into 2 1/2 inch pieces. Arrange on a platter.

2. Slice nectarine and avocado into 1” by 0.25” or smaller slices. Pick the smallest fresh basil leaves off the bunch and set aside. Cut them into thin slices if they are too big. Slice the red chili pepper into very small strips and dice. Discard seeds if you wish to avoid too much heat. Quarter the lime.

3. Drizzle a little olive oil over the fish, add avocado, nectarine, basil, red chili pepper, a squeeze of lime juice and a dash of rock salt and cracked black pepper (optional). Serve with either Peay Viognier or Chardonnay.

Over the July 4th weekend, I gave this recipe a shot on the Wednesday night kick-off of a long weekend party we throw for over a hundred friends. I could not find halibut that was sushi grade fresh but I did find local cod which was perfect. This is easy to prepare with the only qualification that it takes time to cut and assemble so be sure whatever dishes follow do not require lots of your attention with last minute searing or you may not have time to grab a few before they disappear.

More Recipes >

Recent Recipes